Updated at: 15-01-2023 - By: Jane

Simmons and Saatva are two of the most well-known names in bedding. Simmons was formed in 1870, and Beautyrest was introduced in 1925, as the company’s main product. Saatva is a relatively new company, yet it has already established a loyal following since its 2010 debut.

This comparison guide will only focus on a few models from each company. Both innerspring and hybrid types are available, as well as the Saatva HD and Saatva Latex Hybrid. This includes Simmons Beautyrest Black, the Simmons Beautyrest Black+Cooling hybrid, and the Simmons Beautyrest Black+Comfort hybrid.

Firmnesses range from mild (3) to medium (5) to medium-firm (6) in Saatva’s four variants (7-8). It is possible to choose between a medium-soft (4) and a medium-firm mattress with the Beautyrest Black mattress line (6). Mattresses in the center of the 10-point firmness scale, such as a 5 or 6, are preferred by the majority of people. While heavier people typically want a stiffer form for support, lighter people prefer a softer type for better contouring.

Each of the Saatva and Beautyrest Black mattresses described above will be covered in this guide. Among other things, it will look at their build quality, operational performance, cost, and size. Learning more about each of these mattress models might help you decide which one is best for you and your sleeping habits.

The only Saatva mattresses we’ll be comparing here are those that contain the Saatva name. The Loom & Leaf memory foam mattress, the Zenhaven flippable latex mattress, and the Solaire adjustable airbed are not covered in this guide.

Saatva vs Beautyrest Black: Which is Better for You?

Then, which of these new mattresses is the best fit for your needs? There is a lot to consider! Make your way through this list to see which of these beds would be a good fit for your lifestyle.

Who Should Buy Saatva

  • The Saatva is a better value for money solution for those on a tight budget.
  • The Saatva could be ideal for you if you’re a mixed sleeper. You should be able to quickly switch positions on both mattresses, but the Saatva has a little more bounce to it.
  • For those who are concerned about the sleep trial time, Saatva offers nearly twice as many nights as Beautyrest, thus this could be a benefit.

Who Should Buy Beautyrest

  • Beautyrest’s extra-cool cover will be appreciated by hot sleepers who want to keep cool while they sleep.
  • In my opinion, couples will also like the Beautyrest because of its excellent edge support and amazing motion isolation. In other words, you won’t have to worry about a restless spouse interfering with your enjoyment of the mattress.
  • If you like a firmer mattress, the Beautyrest Black may be a better alternative for you than the Saatva. 
  • For those who sleep on their stomach as well as their back or side, these mattresses are a good choice.

Neither of these beds is quite soft enough for side sleepers. Consider purchasing a mattress that provides extra support in the areas where you feel the most pain. You may try one of our top-rated memory foam mattresses.

Saatva vs Beautyrest Black: Similarities and Differences

Let’s take a closer look at the similarities and differences between these two mattresses before we get into the specifics. Check out our comprehensive Saatva mattress review and Beautyrest Black mattress review for additional in-depth information.

Both Saatva and Beautyrest have a wide variety of mattress options (we’re focusing on the classic Saatva and the Beautyrest Black in this review), so it’s important to keep this in mind. Mattresses from both of these brands are also available in various firmness levels. Saatva Luxury Firm and Beautyrest Black L-Class Medium will be reviewed.

Main Similarities

  • Both of these mattresses have a lot of bounce and support thanks to their innerspring construction.
  • This is a terrific option for those who prefer a more classic look, as well as those who sleep in multiple positions.
  • Firmness is ideal for back and stomach sleepers, who can enjoy both mattresses.

Mattresses have reinforced edges. With the additional edge support, these mattresses will appear to be larger than a foam mattress of same size.

Main Differences

  • The Beautyrest Black mattress is more expensive than the Saatva mattress.
  • The cooling BlackICETM cover of the Beautyrest Black keeps you more comfortable at night than the Saatva.
  • In terms of motion isolation, the Beautyrest Black is superior to the Saatva. To put it another way, if your companion gets restless on the Beautyrest, you’ll be less likely to be bothered by it.

At contrast to Saatva, Beautyrest mattresses are also available in brick-and-mortar locations.

Sizing and Weight Options

Consider the mattress’s size and weight, even if you don’t think they’re the first things you’ll look at when making your purchase.

Because the mattress size impacts how much surface area sleepers have, couples and those who toss and turn prefer larger mattresses. In addition to being more portable and less expensive, smaller choices have specific advantages. Small-room dwellers, on the other hand, may necessitate a smaller mattress.

How supportive a mattress feels depends on its height. Larger people choose thicker models because they provide a deeper level of comfort and support and are therefore less likely to collapse under their own weight. When it comes to getting in and out of bed, height might play a role. While some sleepers like a higher bed, others prefer a lower one since it is easier to get in and out of. As a final consideration, high-profile models often necessitate sheets with large pockets, which may be of interest to some buyers.

Finally, the weight of a mattress is something to keep in mind. Consider a lighter mattress if you plan to move or rotate it frequently. Heavy choices may, however, feel more stable on the ground.



Saatva Classic

  • Height: 11.5″, 14.5″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Split King, California King, Split California King

Saatva HD

  • Height: 15.5″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King

Saatva Youth

  • Height: 10″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full

Saatva Latex Hybrid

  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King

Beautyrest Black

Beautyrest Black

  • Height: 13″, 13.5″, 15″
  • Size Options: Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Beautyrest Black + Cooling Upgrade

  • Height: 13″
  • Size Options: Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Beautyrest Black + Cooling + Comfort Upgrade

  • Height: 15″
  • Size Options: Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

There are more mattress sizes to choose from at Saatva. In addition to the regular twin, full, queen, king and California king sizes, the Saatva Classic is available in split king and split California king for couples with adjustable beds. It is also available in full, twin XL, full, queen and king sizes. Split king versions of the Saatva HD and Saatva Latex Hybrid are also available. There are just three sizes available for the Saatva Youth: twin (twin XL), and full (large).

It is not possible to purchase Beautyrest Black mattresses in twin size, but they are available for purchase in the other five regular mattress sizes. This mattress does not come in split sizes.

Customers opting for a lower-profile bed may prefer Saatva’s offerings over Beautyrest Black’s high-profile versions. The Saatva Youth, at 10 inches, is the slenderest model offered by either company. The Saatva HD, on the other hand, is the thickest at 15.5 inches.

Saatva’s mattresses are also heavier than Beautyrest Black’s. Both brands’ previous models are heavier than the Saatva Youth, which is lighter.

Both Saatva and Beautyrest Black have comprehensive product lines, however they are vastly different. In order to meet the needs of diverse customers, the Saatva Classic is available in three firmness levels and two heights. Each of the Saatva Latex Hybrid and Youth mattresses is created for a specific group of people, while the Saatva HD mattress is best suited to those who weigh more than 230 pounds. The Beautyrest Black series has fewer options because it focuses on a single basic design with two temperature and feel adjustments.

Construction and Materials Comparison

Mattresses are distinguished by their materials and construction, among other things. These elements not only affect the comfort of a mattress, but they also help it last longer. Each common mattress material has its own set of advantages and disadvantages. A mattress’s materials can tell you a lot about how it will feel to sleep on it.

Mattresses with coils, latex, polyfoam, and memory foam are among the most common. In order to create a good balance between support and contouring, many mattress models use a variety of materials.

A mattress’s support layer is often made up of coils or springs; some models also utilize them in the transition or comfort layers. Coil layers are typically used to regulate temperature because they allow air to circulate freely between springs. Oftentimes, they also include increased edge support to improve the bed’s useful area. In many couples, the bounce of a coil system is beneficial for sex, although this attribute could lead to additional motion transmission, especially if the bed has a thin comfort layer.

Latex is praised for its bounce, breathability, durability, and ability to relieve pressure. Latex that is made from natural resources is also environmentally friendly. Latex mattresses, on the other hand, tend to be more expensive and less effective at isolating motion than polyfoam or memory foam mattresses. Comfort, transition, and core layers can all benefit from latex.

It is possible to utilize polyfoam in any layer of a mattress. In order to relieve pressure spots, it molds itself to a sleeper’s body and soon returns to its original shape, making it easier to get out of bed. While high-density polyfoam can be quite long-lasting, lower-density polyfoam degrades more quickly than some other materials.

It’s usual to find memory foam in the comfort and transition layers. Pressure comfort that many sleepers compare to a hug can be found in this material. Memory foam tends to retain body impressions longer than other materials, which may make it more difficult for some sleepers to shift positions.. However, certain versions use specific elements to avoid trapping heat against the sleeper’s body due to its close-hug design.


Saatva Classic

In the Saatva Classic, the innerspring design is based on a hybrid. To begin, this mattress has an organic knit cover that allows air to flow into the sleeping surface. The cover is quilted with a luxurious Euro pillow top made of 1.25 inches of polyfoam,.75 inches of fiber fill, and 1 ounce of Dacron.

Two thin layers of foam provide additional support and shaping. For appropriate spinal alignment, the mattress has a.625-inch polyfoam layer that molds around the sleeper’s body, while the.375-inch memory foam lumbar pad provides additional support in this area.

Individual 14.5-gauge coils are enclosed in foam in the transition layer, which is 4 inches in length. Additionally, the coils in this layer move independently of one another to prevent motion transfer.

In order to provide support, bounce, and airflow, the mattress’s 11.5-inch and 14.5-inch cores are both built of 13-gauge hourglass coils. There is a 4-inch core in the 11.5-inch mattress, and a 7-inch core in the 14.5-inch mattress. Edge support is provided by a thick layer of firm foam on the outside of the bed. The support foundation is made up of a.5-inch loft pad and a.875-inch fiber pad.

Saatva HD

Designed to accommodate larger bodies, the Saatva HD mattress is a hybrid mattress.

Using organic cotton and polyfoam to cushion the bed’s surface, a hand-tufted cover is created. Uses Talalay latex to ease pressure points while keeping a buoyant, responsive sensation in its top layer of the comfort system, which is 1.5 inches thick. Support under the shoulders and hips is bolstered by five zones of firmness to prevent sagging and keep the sleeper’s spine in alignment. High density 5 pounds per cubic foot (PCF) memory foam is used in the second comfort layer for enhanced contouring, pressure alleviation and isolation of movement.

The polyfoam transition layer is 2 inches thick and separates the core from the comfort system. Adding offset coils to the core improves the mattress’s breathability, support, and bounce. 12.5 gauge coils are strung through the spring system with 17-gauge helical wire for extra strength and isolation. Extra edge support is provided by polyfoam encasing the mattress.


Saatva Latex Hybrid

The Saatva HD mattress is a hybrid mattress designed to accommodate larger people.

The surface of the bed is cushioned by a hand-tufted organic cotton cover that is quilted with polyfoam. Uses Talalay latex to ease pressure points while retaining a buoyant, responsive feel in its top layer of the comfort system (1.5 inches). In order to prevent sagging and maintain the sleeper’s spine upright, the mattress has five zones of firmness. High density 5 pounds per cubic foot (PCF) memory foam is used in the second comfort layer for enhanced contouring, pressure alleviation and isolation of movement.

Comfort and core systems are separated by a polyfoam transition layer of 2 inches. Breathability, support and bounce are enhanced by the use of offset coils in the mattress’ core. Coils of 12.5 gauge are threaded with 17-gauge helical wire for increased durability and motion isolation in this spring system Polyfoam is used to encase the mattress’s perimeter for additional edge support.

Saatva Youth

Children’s flippable innerspring watch, the Saatva Youth. One side is for youngsters ages 3 and up, while the other is for those ages 8 and above.

The mattress is supported by a layer of 14.5-gauge bonnell coils located in the middle of the bed. The edge of the coil system is stabilized by a polyfoam encasement around the outer perimeter.

This mattress has a polyfoam comfort layer that is zoned to support the sleeper’s spine on one side of the mattress. Soften the bed’s surface by adding a layer of convoluted high-density polyfoam.

The organic cotton cover of the Saatva Youth Mattress is hypoallergenic and breathable. There is a waterproof barrier inside the mattress and a water-resistant cover to safeguard the mattress from mishaps.

Simmons Beautyrest Black

Beautyrest Black

This is the most expensive hybrid mattress in the Black collection, the Beautyrest Black. The temperature of the bed is controlled using a BlackICE 4.0 technology that is unique to this model. This comes with a fabric cover designed to feel cool to the touch. It then uses four levels of comfort to support the sleeper’s body and alleviate pain areas. There are a lot of layers to this.. 1 inch, 1.5 inches, and… of polyfoam make up the. Gel-infused memory foam that is 5 inches thick.

The mattress’s core is made up of individual coils. The springs give the mattress a little bounce, while the mattress’s core provides additional airflow to keep it cool. Vibrations can be reduced by moving each coil on its own. An outer layer of polyfoam provides additional edge support.

Beautyrest Black + Cooling

Compared to the flagship Beautyrest Black, the Beautyrest Black + Cooling has improved cooling functions. It has a cloth cover that is cool to the touch. In addition, there is a four-layer system of comfort under the skin, which includes. RightTemp Memory Foam, Gel-infused Memory Foam, and Polyfoam fill up the mattress. Carbon fiber is included into RightTemp Memory Foam to improve temperature regulation. Using this comfort technique, the mattress is cushioned and the sleeper’s weight is evenly distributed to alleviate pressure.

Additionally, this model has a pocketed coil core, which enhances breathability and springiness while reducing motion transfer. The edge is reinforced with a polyfoam encasement.

Beautyrest Black + Cooling + Comfort

The Beautyrest Black + Cooling + Comfort mattress is a hybrid like the rest of the Beautyrest Black mattresses. It has better cooling and comfort features than the other variants.

Surface-level cooling is provided via a cloth cover that is pleasant to the touch. Five layers make up the comfort system:. One inch polyfoam, two inches gel-infused memory foam, one inch right-temp memory foam, and one inch polyfoam make up 75 inches of GelTouch Foam. Polyurethane GelTouch Foam is a unique polyfoam designed to alleviate pressure and promote airflow. Another unique substance is RightTemp Memory Foam. To keep the bed cool, it is impregnated with carbon fiber. This comfort system is designed to be soft, alleviate pressure, and keep the wearer cool and comfortable.

Finally, the Beautyrest Black + Cooling + Comfort mattress’s core is made up of pocketed coils, which provide bounce and breathability. As a result, the coils’ pocketing reduces the amount of motion that can be transferred. The coil system is encased in a layer of polyfoam for added edge support.

Average Customer Ratings

Is it possible to buy a mattress that you haven’t tried? Customer evaluations are a great way to get a sense of how a product might function for you based on the experiences of other people who have used it. This can be a signal of trust that gives you the confidence to buy.

When reading customer feedback, keep in mind that comfort is a subjective matter. Because people have different preferences for comfort, customer reviews can be inconsistent. If you’re shopping for a mattress, this can be a bit of a challenge, but you can get around it by checking for particular criticism in the customer reviews. For the most part, customers have strong feelings about their mattress, which we’ll go into more depth about in the sections that follow. To get a better idea of how a mattress will feel to you, look for reviews that include these features.


ModelAverage Rating
Saatva Classic 4.9/5
Saatva HD 4.9/5
Saatva Latex Hybrid
Saatva Youth

Beautyrest Black

ModelAverage Rating
Beautyrest Black 4.5/5
Beautyrest Black + Cooling Upgrade 4.5/5
Beautyrest Black + Cooling + Comfort Upgrade 4.5/5

In-Depth Ratings

A mattress’s overall comfort is influenced by a variety of factors. The following are some of the most commonly sought-after features in a mattress. Personal tastes, inclinations, and sleep habits can influence which traits are most important. However, choosing a mattress that works best for you may help you sleep better and wake up less frequently.

Durable mattresses last longer because they are less prone to drooping, indentations, and degradation of the mattress’s foam. Mattresses made of high-grade materials are more likely to last longer than those made of lower quality materials. Durable models are more expensive, but their longer lifespans may make them more cost-effective in the long term. People who don’t like shopping for a new mattress and wish to keep their current one in place for as long as feasible may also find durability crucial.

Motion Isolation
Motion-absorbing mattresses are preferred by those who share a bed with a spouse because they don’t disturb their sleep. It’s possible that a partner can feel the vibrations caused by a shift in one sleeper’s posture. Sleeping on a bed that is well-isolated from movement may result in a better night’s rest. Those with more substantial comfort layers, such as memory foam or polyfoam, are usually better at dampening movement.

The quality of a mattress’ s sex appeal can be influenced by a variety of factors. Many couples want a bouncing surface, therefore models with coils or latex are popular. While a snug-fitting comfort system may limit mobility, it can also provide traction, which some people find appealing. Couples may find it more convenient to move about on a mattress with good edge support. In order to be more discrete, some partners may prefer a model that makes less noise.

Temperature Neutrality
As you sleep, your body generates heat, which can be trapped by some mattresses, while others allow it to dissipate. When it comes to sleeping, people who have a tendency to overheat prefer a model that is designed to keep them cool at night. Because of their breathability, latex and coils are excellent in maintaining a balanced body temperature. Additionally, polyfoam’s open-cell structure allows heat to be dissipated. When it comes to heat retention, memory foam is more susceptible, although many mattress designs include unique materials or features that keep the sleep surface cool.

Pressure Relief
Aches and pains may occur for certain people while they sleep because their wider, heavier bodies exert extra pressure on the mattress. Pressure can build up around a person’s hips and shoulders while they’re sleeping, which can be uncomfortable. The weight of the sleeper is redistributed to reduce pressure building in models with good pressure relief. Most of a mattress’s pressure reduction comes from its comfort system. Generally speaking, polyfoams, memory foams, and latexes function best.

Mattresses with synthetic foam or compressed shipping often have manufacturing odors trapped in them. Many people perceive off-gassing odors to be innocuous, so they don’t give them much thought. If the mattress is kept in a well-ventilated area, most odors will dissipate within a few days. As a result, those who are sensitive to odors may prefer a model that is less prone to emit an unpleasant aroma.

Ease of Movement
Some people may find it more difficult to get out of a mattress that responds slowly to changes in pressure, hugs the body, and/or allows the sleeper to sink in deeply. As a result of its long response time, memory foam might make some people feel like they’re stuck in their bed. Those with substantial memory foam comfort layers are more likely to suffer from this issue. In the case of those with mobility challenges or those who regularly change positions, a model that is more easily moved may be preferable to them.

Edge Support
A bed with a supporting perimeter may be preferred by those who want to sit or sleep towards the bed’s edge. It’s common knowledge that people won’t sleep near the bed’s edge if they don’t feel safe doing so. As a result, the mattress’s useable surface is reduced. Stable edges can be achieved without the need for additional edge reinforcement in firmer models and those with substantial support layers. There are a number of types with coil layers that use specialized materials and building techniques to provide support around the perimeter.



Saatva ClassicSaatva HDSaatva Latex HybridSaatva Youth
FirmnessSoft (3), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8)Firm (7)Medium Firm (6)Medium (5), Firm (7)
Durability 4/5 4/5 3/5 3/5
Motion Isolation 3/5 2/5 3/5 3/5
Sex 3/5 4/5 4/5 N/A/5
Sleeps Cool 4/5 5/5 4/5 3/5
Pressure Relief 4/5 3/5 3/5 3/5
Off-Gassing 5/5 4/5 4/5 3/5
Ease of Movement 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5
Edge Support 4/5 4/5 4/5 3/5

Beautyrest Black

Beautyrest BlackBeautyrest Black + Cooling UpgradeBeautyrest Black + Cooling + Comfort Upgrade
FirmnessMedium Soft (4), Medium Firm (6)Medium Firm (6)Medium Soft (4)
Durability 4/5 4/5 4/5
Motion Isolation 3/5 3/5 4/5
Sex 3/5 3/5 2/5
Sleeps Cool 3/5 4/5 3/5
Pressure Relief 4/5 4/5 4/5
Off-Gassing 3/5 3/5 3/5
Ease of Movement 3/5 3/5 3/5
Edge Support 3/5 3/5 3/5

Prices and Sizing

One of the most significant determinants of mattress cost is the quality of the materials used in its construction. As a result, thicker mattresses tend to be more expensive than their smaller, thinner counterparts.

As a result of the higher costs associated with using higher-quality and more modern materials, consumers frequently pay more for their mattresses. A mattress is an essential investment, and higher-priced materials may improve the bed’s longevity and comfort for some customers.

The location of a mattress’s manufacturing facility can also have an impact on its final cost. Because of the higher costs of manufacturing and labor in the United States, imported models tend to be more expensive.


Saatva ClassicSaatva HDSaatva Latex HybridSaatva Youth
Twin XL$1,087$1,687$1,274$799
California King$1,974$2,974$2,249
Split King$2,174$3,374$2,548
Split California King$2,174

Beautyrest Black

Beautyrest BlackBeautyrest Black + Cooling UpgradeBeautyrest Black + Cooling + Comfort Upgrade
Twin XL$2249$2749$2949
California King$3199$3999$4199
Split King
Split California King

The Beautyrest Black mattress range is more expensive than Saatva’s mattress line on average. However, for those who prefer a mattress on the softer end of the usual firmness spectrum, this additional cost may be warranted. Customers who like long-established brands may also believe that the additional cost is worth it.

The Saatva Youth and the Saatva Classic are the cheapest options from each brand. As a result of its additional features and cutting-edge technology, the Simmons Beautyrest Black + Cooling + Comfort costs the most.

Trials, Warranty, and Delivery



Saatva’s mattresses come with free White Glove delivery to any address in the 48 contiguous states. Saatva does not currently ship to Alaska and Hawaii, but the company can work with a freight forwarder to get the product there.

Customers’ orders for mattresses are normally filled in the order in which they are received. Most mattresses are delivered within 1-2 weeks, but this can vary depending on the location of the customer’s location. Customers may expect a four-hour window in which a delivery staff will bring their new mattress into their home, remove its packaging, set it up, and dispose of their old mattress.

Customers can purchase a Saatva mattress online. The Saatva.com Viewing Room in New York City is another place where they can see Saatva’s models up close and personal.

Simmons Beautyrest Black

The continental United States is eligible for complimentary White Glove delivery of Simmons Beautyrest mattresses purchased online. At this moment, Beautyrest mattresses purchased online cannot be delivered to Alaska or Hawaii.

XPO Logistics, the company’s shipping partner, will contact you to schedule a four-hour delivery window after you place your order. After an order is placed, a representative from XPO Logistics will contact you within 7 to 15 business days. Your new mattress will be delivered, unpacked, and the packing will be removed, and then your old mattress will be removed.

In addition to the Beautyrest website and Amazon, certain mattress and furniture stores around the United States carry Beautyrest Black mattresses.

Sleep Trial


During the 180-night trial period, consumers can test out Saatva mattresses in the comfort of their own homes. Customers can return the mattress at any point throughout the trial term for a full refund of the purchase price. Saatva will take care of the mattress removal process. In this case, a cab fare of $99 has to be paid. In most cases, discarded mattresses are donated or made available to the staff at the delivery location.

In addition to free returns, there is a $99 shipping cost and a 180-night sleep trial on the new mattress.

Simmons Beautyrest Black

Simmons Beautyrest Black models come with a 100-night sleep trial when purchased straight from Simmons. When a consumer is not satisfied with their mattress, they can return it and get a full refund. Customer service representatives from Simmons will work with them so that they may arrange for free removal of the mattress from their residence. In this arrangement, each household can receive one refund every year.

Return procedures for Beautyrest Black mattresses at other retailers may differ.



In most cases, warranty agreements include a replacement mattress at no extra cost. Indents and foam cracks are some of the most common faults that can be covered by a policy, however the length of coverage varies from company to company. With a robust warranty policy, buyers can be assured that their new mattress will last for years to come.

Consider what is expected of you as a customer and what is covered and not covered by the firm’s warranty policy, as well as how the company pledges to remedy faults, while looking at a warranty policy. If a fault arises, these variables may determine whether or not your mattress is eligible for compensation.


As for warranties, Saatva’s Youth model has a 12-year guarantee, while the Classic and Hybrid models each get 15 years and the HD has a 20-year guarantee. For defective materials and craftsmanship, as well as qualified body impressions, these warranties are available. Only impressions greater than 1 inch are covered by the Saatva Classic and Youth plans, while impressions greater than 1.5 inches are covered by the Saatva HD policy.

Saatva offers free mattress replacements for the first two years of the warranty. Saatva will repair and re-cover mattresses with qualifying problems for the remainder of the warranty period for a cost of $99 per way.

“Fairness Replacement Option” is also available. Mattresses can be kept by consumers instead of being sent back, and new ones purchased at a prorated fee based on the length of time they’ve had their current mattress. Transportation costs may be incurred by the consumer.

Additional terms and conditions are in effect.

Simmons Beautyrest Black

In the United States, Simmons Beautyrest Black mattresses come with a 10-year limited guarantee that covers manufacture and materials defects. To be covered by this coverage, you must be the original owner of the mattress.

As soon as Simmons discovers a qualifying flaw in a mattress, it can choose to replace only that part or the entire thing.

Mattresses must be used on a good base and must be free of abuse, misuse, and stains in order to be eligible for warranty coverage. The white law tag on the mattress should either be left on or saved by the customer. Additional terms and conditions are in effect.

What Do These Mattresses Feel Like?

Next, let’s take a closer look at how these beds could feel to sleep on! I’ll begin with a sense of resoluteness. Mattresses can feel different depending on your body type and favorite posture while you sleep. I’m 5’10” and 190 pounds, and I prefer to sleep on my stomach.


If you want a firmer mattress, the Saatva mattress has three options: Plush, Luxury Firm and Firm. On the firmness scale, I scored the Luxury Firm model a 7 out of 10. The industry standard for medium firmness is a 6.5 out of 10 rating.

The Saatva made me feel safe and secure, as though my spine was properly aligned. Because I had the sensation of lying on top of the mattress instead of “in” it, I was able to switch positions with ease, which is essential for combination sleepers.

I experienced some discomfort in my shoulders and hips when I shifted my weight to my side, therefore I wouldn’t recommend this mattress for side sleepers. For those who like to sleep on their stomachs, this mattress should provide adequate hip support.

Beautyrest Black

According to my firmness rating, the Beautyrest Black mattress is a solid 8 out of 10. I found it to be a tad more firm than the Saatva. There is a lot of support in the mattress because to the pocketed coils and strong poly foam transition layer, and the memory foam comfort layer is thin enough to maintain its firmness.

For those who sleep on their back or stomach, this mattress is ideal. This mattress is best suited for stomach sleepers who like a firmer mattress. Keeping the hips from sinking in helps keep the spine aligned in these poses, which is a good thing. Side sleepers, on the other hand, may find this mattress overly hard since they may feel shoulder jamming. In order to get the best of both worlds, side sleepers should consider the Beautyrest Hybrid mattress.

Some pressure relief is provided by a layer of gel memory foam on top of the Beautyrest. A good fit for your body is achieved by this layer. It also provides a degree of isolation from external vibrations. This suggests that it could be a hit among couples. On this bed, a restless spouse shouldn’t bother you too much. However, if you’re prone to being bothered by a snoring spouse, a foam mattress may be the better option.

Comparing Saatva and Beautyrest Black Mattress Materials

After that, let’s have a peek at the inside of each of these mattresses to see what gives them their unique sensations.


  • Cover —In addition to being breathable and antimicrobial, the organic cotton cover of the Saatva is hypoallergenic. It’s soft and cuddly to the touch, making it ideal for snuggling.
  • Comfort Layer — A euro pillow top covers the top layer of the Saatva. It acts as a buffer between the mattress and the sleeper’s body.
  • Support Layer — Next is a layer of individually wrapped pocketed coils that serves as a foundation. Bounce, ventilation, and support are all present.
  • Zoned Support Layer — The Saatva has a layer of memory foam in the middle that provides some lower back support. For those who suffer from lower back pain, this is a welcome addition.
  • Foundation Layer — Steel coils form the foundation of the Saatva’s structure. The additional lift and support provided by the second coil layer is remarkable.
  • Edge Support — High-density foam covers the entire mattress. This suggests that the Saatva has a significant advantage. Ideally, this mattress should be able to support you even if you roll all the way to one side.

Beautyrest Black

  • Cover — Polyester and rayon are used in the cover’s construction, which allows it to breathe and keep the bed cooler while you sleep on it. Polyfoam is sandwiched between two layers of quilting, allowing sleepers to sink into the mattress from the get-go.
  • Comfort layer — After that, a thin layer of memory foam with gel infusion is applied. It alleviates some pressure points without compromising the bed’s general support or engulfing the occupant. An injection of gel helps to cool the body of a sleeper.
  • Transition layer — The transition layer is constructed of poly foam, which is a little harder than the memory foam that covers the top of the mattress. Transitioning from memory foam to pocketed coils is made easier by this layer.
  • Support layer — The transition layer is constructed of poly foam, which is a little harder than the memory foam that covers the top layer of comfort. To smooth the transition from memory foam to pocketed coils, this layer has been added.
  • Edge support — It has a similar high-density polyfoam layer to the Saatva, which increases edge support while allowing individuals and couples to use the entire surface area of this bed.

Saatva vs. Beautyrest Black: Best Qualities

Whew! Saatva and Beautyrest Black mattresses are almost at the end of our Saatva vs. Beautyrest Black comparison review! What is the best mattress for you? That’s a question I can’t answer, but the following sections will assist you make a decision!

Saatva Best Features

  • Combo sleepers will benefit greatly from the Saatva. On this bed, it’s simple to change positions during the night.
  • If you sleep on your back or stomach, you’ll love the Saatva’s solid support.
  • The Saatva is less expensive than the Beautyrest for those on a tight budget. It is, in fact, a bargain for a high-end mattress.

Beautyrest Black Best Features

  • As a firm and supportive mattress, the Beautyrest Black is ideal for people who sleep on their backs or stomachs and need a lot of help keeping their hips and spine in proper alignment.
  • For those who are concerned about overheating while they sleep, this mattress may be a smart choice for them as well. With its breathable cover and gel-infused memory foam, this mattress is ideal for those who prefer to sleep coolly.
  • As a last bonus, couples will appreciate the Beautyrest Black’s cooling technology and additional edge support.

Our Recommendations

Choose the Saatva if…

  • You’re plagued by aches and pains all the time.
  • You and your partner like sleep surfaces that respond to your movement.
  • You’re prone to overheating while you’re asleep.

Choose the Simmons Beautyrest Black Mariela if…

  • You enjoy the way high-profile beds make you feel.
  • You and your partner like sleep surfaces that respond to your movement.
  • You’re prone to overheating while you’re asleep.

Our Review Process

Each mattress is put through its paces by a member of the Sleepopolis team. Unpacking the mattress helps us determine how difficult or easy it is to get the mattress from the box to the mattress. After that, we’ll spend some time lying on the bed in various positions to get a better sense of how it feels on our backs, stomachs, and sides, just to be sure. Our Sleepopolis testing, which utilize specialized equipment to gauge properties like as motion transmission, bounce, and pressure relief, are the next step in the process. Finally, we’ll open the mattress and inspect each layer. We may now come to a final conclusion on the mattress after following these processes. So, let’s get back to the mattress reviews.

Rate this post