Updated at: 15-01-2023 - By: Jane

Each of Saatva and Amerisleep sells a carefully chosen collection of mattresses, offering clients a variety of alternatives based on their body type and sleeping pattern.

The Saatva Classic, Saatva’s flagship mattress, is a coil-on-coil hybrid with configurable firmness and thickness levels. Saatva also provides two other adult-friendly mattress models: the Saatva HD, a hybrid mattress suited for anyone weighing more over 230 pounds, and the Saatva Latex Hybrid, which is made entirely of eco-friendly materials. Along with these variants, Saatva offers the Saatva Youth, a reversible innerspring designed specifically for children. Not every mattress manufacturer caters to such a diverse range of body shapes, and Saatva is an appealing option for clients upset by other companies’ restricted selection.

Additionally, Amerisleep aims to satisfy a variety of preferences. The company offers five different firmness degrees of memory foam mattresses. Amerisleep is the only one of the five that caters to the majority of sleeping types. Amerisleep employs less petroleum-based foams, which may appeal to eco-conscious buyers seeking the feel of an all-foam mattress. A few Amerisleep models are now available as hybrid models with zoned, pocketed coil support cores rather than polyfoam bases.

Both firms provide excellent value for money, with high-quality goods built to endure longer than the ordinary mattress. We’ll examine the Amerisleep and Saatva mattresses in detail, providing you with all the information you need to choose the ideal mattress for you.

Amerisleep vs. Saatva Overview

Amerisleep is a well-known bed-in-a-box firm that prides itself on offering clients a variety of options. They sell hybrid and memory foam mattresses, however our comparison will focus on the Amerisleep AS3 Hybrid particularly. This mattress, being one of Amerisleep’s greatest sellers, is suitable for a wide variety of sleepers.

Saatva is a luxury internet mattress brand that, unlike many other competitors, does not compress its mattresses into cardboard boxes.

Saatva Solaire, Loom & Leaf, and Saatva Latex Hybrid are all popular models. We’ll examine the Saatva Classic 11.5-inch Luxury Firm model in our mattress comparison.

Both mattresses provide great qualities, but they will appeal to different people. Continue scrolling to get a sneak glimpse of who would prefer each bed.

Who Should Get the Amerisleep?

  • Individuals seeking a medium-firm mattress.
  • Sleepers on their backs.
  • Couples.

Who Should Get the Saatva?

  • Individuals seeking a little firmer bed.
  • Sleepers on their stomachs.
  • Those who are not interested in waiting for their mattress to degas and expand.

Amerisleep vs. Saatva: Top Similarities

When comparing mattresses, we always begin by examining the similarities between the two brands. Let us examine the similarities between the Amerisleep and Saatva beds!

  • Mattresses by Saatva and Amerisleep have a responsive feel.
  • Both mattresses are hybrids with coils at the base and foam on top.
  • Both are extremely well-ventilated.
  • Both provide extremely accommodating sleep trial periods and return policies.
  • Saatva and Amerisleep are both well-known for their outstanding customer service.

Amerisleep vs. Saatva: Key Differences

Now, let’s examine more closely at what distinguishes these two mattresses.

  • Saatva’s mattress is a little firmer.
  • The Amerisleep is 12′′ tall, while the Saatva comes in 11.5′′ and 14.5′′ heights.
  • Amerisleep’s products are slightly more expensive (but customers can save with coupons).
  • Because Amerisleep is sent in a box, it requires time to decompress and expand. Saatva’s delivery service is white glove.
  • Saatva is a more suitable option for stomach sleepers.

Sizing and Weight Options

Consider the size, height, and weight of the mattress as one of the initial steps in the mattress selection process. Are you intending to use it in conjunction with your current bed frame? Are you confined to a small space? Mattresses that are unavailable in the size you require may need to be eliminated from your list.

For individuals with mobility challenges, a mattress and base that are at a comfortable height above the floor might make getting in and out of bed easier. As an aside, mattresses with higher-than-average profile heights will require deep-pocket fitted sheets, which may add to your budget.

The mattress’s weight is critical for persons who intend to move it frequently, such as while relocating. Additionally, bulky mattresses can be more difficult to set up and rotate. The weight of a mattress is mostly determined by its type, with all-foam mattresses weighing the least and hybrids and latex mattresses weighing the most.

We’ve outlined the practical specifications of the Saatva and Amerisleep mattresses so you can quickly choose which is best for your home.


Saatva Classic

  • Height: 11.5″, 14.5″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Split King, California King, Split California King

Saatva HD

  • Height: 15.5″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King

Saatva Youth

  • Height: 10″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full

Saatva Latex Hybrid

  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King



  • Height: 10″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King


  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King


  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King


  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King


  • Height: 14″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King

Each mattress is available in the regular six mattress sizes, with the exception of the Saatva Youth, which is only available in twin, twin XL, and large. The Saatva Classic split king and split California king sizes are designed for couples with adjustable bed bases. Split king sizes are also available for the Saatva HD, Saatva Latex Hybrid, and all Amerisleep mattresses.

Amerisleep mattresses range in height from 10 to 14 inches when firm and 10 to 14 inches when plush. Saatva Classic consumers, on the other hand, can choose between an 11.5-inch or 14.5-inch profile with no discernible change in feel. The Saatva HD is significantly taller than the usual mattress due to its several supportive layers. While the Saatva Latex Hybrid is shorter than the Saatva HD, it is still considered a high-profile mattress at 12 inches thick.

Amerisleep mattresses are made entirely of foam and feature memory foam comfort layers. Saatva Classic and Saatva Youth are classified as innersprings, whilst Saatva HD and Saatva Latex Hybrid are classified as hybrids. This makes it simple to choose between Amerisleep and Saatva if you prefer one brand of mattress over the other. All-foam mattresses are lighter than hybrid mattresses, which may be an advantage for individuals who struggle with carrying heavy goods.


Construction and Materials Comparison

After years of trial and error, the majority of mattress manufacturers have landed on a small number of materials that function well in mattresses. These include cushioning materials such as memory foam, polyfoam, latex, cotton, wool, and micro-coils, as well as more robust materials for the support core such as high-density polyfoam, innerspring coils, and stiffer latex.

Manufacturers can tailor mattresses to different types of sleepers by adjusting the thickness, quality, firmness, and other characteristics of these materials. By and large, mattresses are classified as all-foam, innerspring, hybrid, latex, or airbed based on their component materials. While two mattresses of the same type will have certain similarities, each will have its own set of benefits and drawbacks based on its unique composition.

Saatva and Amerisleep are significantly different in terms of construction and materials. We’ll dissect each mattress’s composition and analyze how it influences the sleeping experience.


Saatva Classic

The Saatva Classic mattress is a hybrid mattress with a soft Euro top layer and a coil-on-coil design.

  • Sewn-in material on Eurotop [1.25-inch soft polyfoam, 75-inch fiber fill, 1 oz. Dacron]
  • 625-inch polyfoam layer
  • 375-inch lumbar pad made of memory foam
  • Layer of pocketed coils measuring four inches (foam-encased)
  • 7-inch (11.5-inch profile) or 4-inch (11.5-inch profile) (14.5-inch profile) coils of an hourglass
  • 5-inch and 5-inch.
  • Fiber pad with a length of 875 inches
  • Encased within a foam perimeter

The twin layer of coils gives the mattress the bounce of an innerspring mattress while maintaining a balanced temperature. A quilted organic cotton cover provides additional padding, particularly in the soft and medium variants that include Dacron. The Saatva mattress includes targeted lumbar support and a perimeter encasement of high-density polyfoam.

The Saatva Classic is available in three distinct firmness levels: Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm. Most sleepers should be able to find the proper hardness level for them among the three possibilities. Customers can also pick between an 11.5-inch or a 14.5-inch profile for practical reasons. The variation is in the height of the hourglass coils and has no bearing on the how the bed feels.

Saatva HD

The Saatva HD has a robust design that provides the necessary support for sleepers weighing more than 300 pounds:

  • Cotton that is organic (quilted in pillow top)
  • 1.5″ Talalay latex (5 zones)
  • 1.5″ thick memory foam
  • 2″ of polyfoam
  • Coils with an offset configuration encased in polyfoam

Zoned latex, active wire lumbar support, and bigger coils all contribute to tailored pressure alleviation while still providing the necessary support for heavier sleepers. Due to the latex and innerspring support core, the Saatva HD mattress is extremely breathable and easy to move around on. As with the Saatva Classic, the mattress features an organic cotton pillow top and a reinforced perimeter.

Saatva Latex Hybrid

The Saatva Latex Hybrid mattress provides outstanding support and a long-lasting construction that incorporates several eco-friendly materials:

  • Organic cotton cover certified by GOTS
  • Organic wool fire barrier approved by GOTS 3″ ventilated Talalay latex 8″ zonal pocketed coils (14.5-gauge perimeter, 13.75-gauge interior)
  • Eco-friendly “Eco Loft” pad

Latex hybrids such as this one are ideal for folks who want the feel of coil mattresses but dislike memory foam. Latex conforms pleasantly to the body, but it does not sink as deeply as memory foam, nor does it trap as much body heat. Additionally, the Saatva Latex Hybrid keeps you cool while sleeping due to its breathable organic cotton cover and consistent airflow through the coil system.

Another feature of this mattress is its edge support. The thick pocketed coils are zoned according to gauge, or thickness, with thicker coils placed around the periphery to give bounce-back and minimize sinkage. The majority of people, especially those who weigh more than 230 pounds, should have little difficulty getting on and off the mattress. Due to latex’s inherent resilience, the edges should hold up well over time.

Saatva Youth

The Saatva Youth is a two-sided garment developed for children aged three to twelve, with one side fitted to the demands of growing bodies:

  • Side 1: polyfoam with five zones
  • Convoluted high-density polyfoam on side 2
  • Bonnell coils that are reversible

The flippable innerspring mattress’s second side is more comfortable for children aged three to eight. Children can progress to Side 1, which features zoned polyfoam and active wire lumbar support, as they grow. The bouncy Saatva Youth mattress is designed with children in mind. It features robust edges, a soft organic cotton cover, and a waterproof barrier to protect against life’s small messes.


Amerisleep offers five mattresses that increase in plushness, ending in the AS5, which we grade as medium soft.

Each mattress’s top layer is composed of the same medium-density memory foam, albeit in varying amounts. The transitional layers are composed of foams with varied ILD, or indentation load deflection, which also contributes to the firmness and support adjustment between mattresses. Except for the AS1, which features a 1 inch thicker and somewhat firmer support core, every Amerisleep mattress features the same support core.

A few models include hybrid designs, which substitute a bed of individually pocketed coils for the high-density polyfoam base. The hybrid models offer bounce and breathability while sacrificing some contouring and motion isolation.


The AS1 is Amerisleep’s firmest mattress:

  • 2″ of memory foam (Bio-Pur, open-cell)
  • 8″ high-density polyfoam (Bio-Core)

The AS1 features a single layer of memory foam on top of a support core made of high-density polyfoam. BioPur memory foam is a plant-based, open-cell foam that is supposed to keep you cooler while sleeping than regular memory foam. The support core is made of a harder foam than the other Amerisleep mattresses. The AS1 contours somewhat but maintains the sleeper securely on top of the mattress, which makes it perfect for back and stomach sleepers.


The AS2 features an additional layer for increased cradling:

  • 2″ of memory foam (Bio-Pur, open-cell)
  • Three-inch-thick transitional polyfoam (zoned with Surface Modification Technology)
  • 7″ high-density polyfoam (Bio-Core)

The transitional layer provides a little plusher feel than the AS1, while the zoning aids provide targeted pressure alleviation and support. This mild pressure relief is ideal for back and side sleepers weighing 130–230 pounds, as well as back and stomach sleepers weighing less than 130 pounds.

Additionally, the AS2 is available in a hybrid configuration with individually pocketed coils rather than a polyfoam foundation.


The AS3 shaves an inch off the transition layer in order to reinforce the top comfort layer:

  • 3″ of memory foam (Bio-Pur, open-cell)
  • 2 inches of polyfoam transition (zoned with Surface Modification Technology)
  • 7″ high-density polyfoam (Bio-Core)

The thicker memory foam layer creates a true medium feel. As is the case with the AS2, this mattress features a zoned transitional layer that provides tailored support and pressure reduction. The transitional layer is slightly softer than that of the AS2, which contributes to the bed’s overall velvety feel. The AS3 should provide cushioning pressure alleviation and healthy spinal support for back and side sleepers weighing less than 230 pounds.

Additionally, the AS3 is offered in a hybrid configuration with individually pocketed coils rather than a polyfoam foundation.


The AS4 places the emphasis squarely on the top layer of memory foam:

  • 4″ of memory foam (Bio-Pur, open-cell)
  • Transitional polyfoam 1 inch (zoned with Surface Modification Technology)
  • 7″ high-density polyfoam (Bio-Core)

The AS4’s thick layer of memory foam and 1 inch of soft transitional polyfoam give deep cradling that’s ideal for side sleepers, with the sensation of sleeping “in” rather than “on” the bed. Again, the transitional layer is softer than its predecessor, despite the fact that the support core stays unchanged.


Due to the addition of one additional layer, the AS5 is the softest of the Amerisleep mattresses:

  • 3″ of memory foam (Bio-Pur, open-cell)
  • 2″ transitional polyfoam (ActiveFlex)
  • 2″ transitional polyfoam (zoned with Surface Modification Technology)
  • 7″ high-density polyfoam (Bio-Core)

Amerisleep’s ActiveFlex foam is a convoluted polyfoam that responds rapidly to pressure. It’s quite plush, having a similar stiffness to memory foam. This, combined with the memory foam and transitional polyfoam layers, enables the AS5 mattress to give deep pressure relief that is suitable for side sleepers and individuals weighing less than 130 pounds. Due to the large comfort layer part, the bed has an extra-high profile, which should be considered while purchasing fitted sheets.

Additionally, the AS5 is available in a hybrid configuration with individually pocketed coils rather than a polyfoam foundation.

Average Customer Ratings

After selecting a mattress that you like, it’s a good idea to seek a second opinion. One way to achieve this is to read the reviews of existing clients.

Numerous positive reviews attest to the mattress’s quality. Similarly, user reviews from those who have had the mattress for more than a year may provide insight into its durability. Additionally, customer evaluations can give information on certain characteristics you may be curious about, such as the effectiveness of a phase-change cover in keeping the mattress cool.

While customer evaluations are obviously helpful in your mattress search, it’s also possible to be misled by false or irrelevant ones. Individuals interact differently with the layers of a mattress depending on their body types and favorite sleeping positions, so you’re bound to come across opposing ideas or ones that are irrelevant to your circumstance. It may be beneficial to give more weight to reviews from individuals who have comparable demands to yours. Keep an eye out for reviews that have been compensated or that come from unverified customers.


To assist you, we’ve included the global rankings for Saatva and Amerisleep mattresses.


ModelAverage Rating
Saatva Classic 4.9/5
Saatva HD 4.9/5
Saatva Youth
Saatva Latex Hybrid


ModelAverage Rating
AS1 4.5/5
AS2 4.5/5
AS3 4.5/5
AS4 4.5/5
AS5 4.5/5

In-Depth Ratings

There is no such thing as a one-size-fits-all mattress. Just as each sleeper has their own distinct style, each mattress is best suited to a specific sort of sleeper. To assist you in selecting which qualities are most important to you, we’ve broken down the variables that most significantly affect how a mattress feels.

While lower-quality mattresses may initially perform similarly to higher-end versions, they quickly degrade. Once a mattress begins to droop and loses its ability to relieve pressure and support, it must be changed. A mattress constructed with higher-quality materials and a more sturdy construction will last substantially longer and provide you with more value for your money.

Motion Isolation
Individuals who share a bed understand the critical nature of having a mattress that prevents motion transfer from one side to the other. This is especially true for sensitive sleepers, who are readily roused if their companion changes positions or enters and exits the bed. Generally, materials like as memory foam are the greatest at isolating motion. They are capable of conforming to pressure on a local level, absorbing motion and decreasing nighttime disturbances.

The greatest mattresses for sex are constructed of responsive materials that allow for natural movement. This is why, when it comes to intimate activities, the majority of people choose bouncy latex and hybrid mattresses. Additionally, noise, temperature regulation, and edge support should be considered.

Temperature Neutrality
Sleeping is difficult when you are uncomfortably heated, and certain materials perform better than others in terms of temperature neutrality. If you have a tendency to sleep overheated, go for a latex or hybrid mattress that allows for air circulation. Additionally, choose mattresses that keep you on top of the mattress rather than sinking into it.

Pressure Relief
The body type and preferred sleeping position of a sleeper have a significant impact on how they interact with the mattress. Certain sleepers may be most comfortable on mattresses that conform to their bodies and cushion common pressure points. To avoid pressure build-up, certain sleepers demand harder surfaces that support heavier body parts. The great majority of sleepers ultimately opt for a mattress that strikes a balance between the two.

Off-gassing is the faint odor you may notice when unpacking your mattress. Off-gassing occurs as a result of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) coming into contact with the air during the synthetic foam manufacturing process. The majority of people report that the smell goes away after a few days of airing out the mattress. Individuals who are extremely sensitive to smell, on the other hand, may prefer mattresses made of natural materials.

Ease of Movement
It is critical for combination sleepers to have a mattress that does not hinder movement. While conforming mattresses have a number of advantages, they can give some people the sensation of being “trapped” in their bed. Active sleepers should seek a mattress with a firmer surface and a quick response to pressure, which makes changing sleeping positions simple.

Edge Support
The perimeter of a mattress is especially prone to drooping, which can provide the sensation of rolling off while sitting on or lying near the bed’s edge. Mattresses with reinforced edges, such as those seen in hybrid mattresses, can expand the usable sleeping area and provide additional support for individuals who have difficulty getting into and out of bed.


Saatva ClassicSaatva HDSaatva YouthSaatva Latex Hybrid
FirmnessSoft (3), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8)Firm (7)Medium (5), Firm (7)Medium Firm (6)
Durability 4/5 4/5 3/5 3/5
Motion Isolation 3/5 2/5 3/5 3/5
Sex 3/5 4/5 N/A/5 4/5
Sleeps Cool 4/5 5/5 3/5 4/5
Pressure Relief 4/5 3/5 3/5 3/5
Off-Gassing 5/5 4/5 3/5 4/5
Ease of Movement 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5
Edge Support 4/5 4/5 3/5 4/5


FirmnessFirm (7)Medium Firm (6)Medium (5)Medium Soft (4)Soft (3)
Durability 3/5 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5
Motion Isolation 3/5 4/5 4/5 5/5 5/5
Sex 3/5 3/5 3/5 2/5 3/5
Sleeps Cool 4/5 3/5 3/5 2/5 2/5
Pressure Relief 3/5 4/5 4/5 5/5 5/5
Off-Gassing 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5 2/5
Ease of Movement 3/5 3/5 3/5 2/5 2/5
Edge Support 4/5 3/5 2/5 2/5 2/5

In-Depth Pricing

It is possible to locate a mattress that is both comfortable and supportive on practically any budget. However, those constructed with higher-quality materials may offer additional benefits, such as increased comfort or a longer lifespan. Generally, the following elements influence the pricing of a mattress:

  • The mattress’s kind (innerspring, hybrid, all-foam, latex, or airbed)
  • The depth of the layers
  • The materials that were used, as well as their certifications
  • The country of manufacture and the materials’ origin
  • The cumulative height
  • The incorporation of unique or private characteristics

A greater price tag does not automatically imply a superior mattress. Additionally, you can come across a pricey, top-of-the-line model that performs admirably but is not a good fit for your body shape. Bear in mind your individual needs and desires when determining the mattress’s price.

Due to the development of direct-to-consumer mattress providers and the expansion of Christmas discounts, the majority of people can now afford quality mattresses. Saatva and Amerisleep are two companies that place a premium on making their products more accessible to the general public.


Saatva ClassicSaatva HDSaatva YouthSaatva Latex Hybrid
Twin XL$1,087$1,687$799$1,274
California King$1,974$2,974$2,249
Split King$2,174$3,374$2,548
Split California King$2,174


Twin XL$1,099$1,299$1,499$1,699$1,999
California King$1,599$1,799$1,999$2,199$2,499
Split King$1,898$2,298$2,698$3,098$3,698
Split California King

Saatva and Amerisleep operate on slightly distinct pricing principles, so we’ll examine them separately in this research.

The Saatva Classic is priced between low and medium and is the greatest value of the Saatva mattresses. Given its dual-coil architecture, premium materials, and customizable firmness levels, this mattress should be a sound purchase for any sleeper. Indeed, all three Saatva mattresses are expected to last a long time. Additionally, they include complimentary White Glove delivery, which provides a discount of approximately $150 when compared to other manufacturers’ White Glove delivery prices.

The Saatva HD offers a sturdy structure and a coating of latex to endure additional wear and tear. These qualities result in a higher price point, which may be worthwhile for persons who are overweight. The Saatva Latex Hybrid is somewhat less expensive than the Saatva HD and is priced similarly to the average hybrid model, making it an excellent mid-range alternative for customers. By comparison, the Saatva Youth is more reasonable, although given its intended use with developing youngsters, some parents may find it a bit pricey.

Amerisleep pricing are closely proportional to the thickness of the comfort layers, which has an effect on the mattress’s overall height. The firm AS1 mattress is the most cheap, coming in at an average price for an all-foam mattress. Prices gradually increase up to the AS5 mattress, which comes with a luxury price tag to match its more sophisticated construction.

The primary distinction between Amerisleep and Saatva mattresses is that Amerisleep customers must pay a premium for their firmness level, whereas Saatva Classic customers pay a flat rate regardless of firmness.

Trials, Warranty, and Delivery


The online mattress market exists in large part because of the advent of mattress-in-a-box delivery, which involves shrink-wrapping, compressing, and shipping the mattress directly to the customer’s home via ground shipment. Shipping typically takes a few business days and is frequently free inside the continental United States. When the mattress arrives, all that remains is to remove the plastic and allow the mattress to expand.

Many companies provide White Glove delivery for mattresses that cannot be compressed or for customers who require assistance putting up the mattress. For an additional fee, a third-party delivery team will assemble the mattress and, if necessary, remove your old mattress.

Amerisleep’s boxed mattresses are free to ship inside the continental United States via FedEx. Amerisleep can provide shipping information to customers in Hawaii, Alaska, Canada, and other overseas destinations. Customers who also purchase an adjustable bed frame may be able to arrange for White Glove delivery through a third-party source.

All Saatva mattresses include White Glove delivery as part of the purchase price. Customers who desire to have their old mattress removed for free can select this option during the checkout process. Saatva does not ship outside of the continental United States.


The conventional thinking is that trying out a mattress for a few minutes in a showroom does not really represent how the mattress would feel after a full night’s sleep. This is why practically every mattress sold online comes with a minimum of a 90-night sleep trial. If clients are dissatisfied with the mattress after adequate time to check it out, they can return it for a refund.

Due to the fact that a decompressed mattress will not fit back into the box for return shipping, the company will typically send someone to pick up the mattress. They will ensure that it is donated or recycled ethically. Certain businesses may charge a restocking fee on returned mattresses.

Amerisleep offers a 100-night sleep trial that includes a 30-night obligatory break-in period. Returns are complimentary. During the sleep trial, customers can choose between receiving a refund or exchanging the bed for another firmness model.

Saatva offers a 180-night break-in period on their mattresses. Customers are not required to adhere to a minimum break-in period, but returns incur a $99 processing fee.



Consumers are protected by the mattress warranty following the conclusion of the sleep trial. Mattress guarantees are intended to cover flaws in manufacturing and craftsmanship, such as permanent indentations and sagging. They do not cover regular wear and tear or mattresses that have been abused, overused, neglected, or used without an adequately stable foundation.

While the guarantee is provided free of charge, some companies operate on a prorated basis, which means that customers must pay an increasing percentage of repair or replacement expenses over time. Additionally, mattress returns may be subject to shipping and handling charges.

The Saatva Youth is covered by a 12-year warranty, the Saatva Classic and Saatva Latex Hybrid by a 15-year warranty, and the Saatva HD by a 20-year warranty. The warranty covers visible indentations of at least one inch in diameter in the Saatva Youth and Saatva Classic, and visible indentations of at least 1.5 inch in the Saatva HD. After the first two years, returned mattresses will incur a $99 per-way freight charge. Customers who have a defective mattress may also opt for the Fairness Replacement Option, which allows them to purchase a new one at a discounted rate (plus transportation fees) and keep the defective one.

All Amerisleep mattresses come with a 20-year prorated warranty that covers noticeable indentations of at least 0.75 inches. During the first ten years, the business will repair or replace defective mattresses at its discretion. Following that, consumers are responsible for 50% of the replacement cost, plus shipping and handling.

Firmness and Feel Differences

When purchasing a new mattress, it is critical to evaluate the firmness and feel. Certain individuals like something gentle and slow-moving, while others require additional support. Which mattress is the greatest fit for your sleeping habits?

How Firm Are the Saatva and Amerisleep Mattresses?

The Amerisleep AS3 mattress feels 6.5/10 on our firmness scale – a standard medium-firm. With a top layer of Bio-Pur foam and a bottom layer of coils, the Amerisleep AS3 provides an excellent blend of comfort and support.

On our firmness rating, the Saatva Luxury Firm model is a 7/10. Therefore, if you’re searching for a little firmer mattress than the industry standard, the Saatva is an excellent alternative. The cushion top adds comfort, while the coils give enough support.

Sleeping on the Amerisleep and Saatva Mattresses

Amerisleep’s AS3 is an excellent option for back sleepers. The foundation layer provides additional support for the lumbar region, ensuring that back sleepers remain in appropriate alignment throughout the night. The Amerisleep AS3 mattress, like the Saatva, is a good option for side sleepers. Many people may sink through the memory foam comfort layer and experience shoulder pressure. Stomach sleepers should feel secure on the AS3, but they may prefer the firmness level of the Amerisleep AS1.

The supporting coils and velvety comfort layer of the Saatva make it an excellent choice for back sleepers. This mattress offers excellent lumbar support, which is why it was voted one of the best mattresses for lower back pain and sciatica. While the Saatva Luxury Firm mattress is an excellent choice for side sleepers, certain individuals may require additional plushness. This bed should be comfortable for stomach sleepers, although it is highly dependent on the individual’s body shape.

What Do the Amerisleep and Saatva Mattresses Feel Like?

The Amerisleep AS3 mattress features a bouncy and responsive sensation, which means you won’t feel stuck between the layers. On top of this mattress, it’s still pretty easy to move around.

Even with its plush pillowtop comfort layer, the Saatva has the feel of a standard innerspring mattress. When I lie on the mattress, I do not sink too deeply and retain a nice amount of bounce.

Average Weight Sleepers – 130lbs – 230lbs

The Amerisleep AS3 is an excellent choice for back sleepers weighing between 130 and 230 pounds. However, side sleepers of average weight may find this bed a little too firm. If you like to sleep on your side, we recommend the Amerisleep AS4 or AS5. The AS3 is a reasonable choice for stomach sleepers of ordinary weight; its hardness level should keep hips from sinking too far into the layers.

Back sleepers of average weight should find the Saatva mattress quite pleasant. The coils assist in maintaining proper spinal alignment, while the comfort layers cushion the hips. While some side sleepers may find the Saatva Luxury Firm an excellent choice, it may be too firm for people who weigh more above 230 pounds. If extra pressure relief is required, we recommend the Saatva Plush Soft variant. While stomach sleeping, individuals of medium weight should feel secure. Due to the firmer feel of this mattress, it should help keep the body aligned during the night.

Heavyweight Sleepers – Over 230lbs

Due to the zoned coils of the Amerisleep AS3, heavyweight back sleepers should have ample support. When lying on their side, heavier individuals may feel pressure along their shoulders as they press into the upper comfort layer. Additionally, the Amerisleep AS3 is not a good choice for stomach sleepers who are larger. Individuals in this category may feel their hips sink deeply into the foam layer, which may eventually result in back pain. If you’re a heavier stomach sleeper, we recommend looking for one of the best mattresses for heavy people specifically.

The Saatva Luxury Firm is an excellent choice for back sleepers who weigh less than 230 lbs. Individuals who weigh less than 300 pounds will feel more secure on the Saatva HD. The Saatva is likely to be a good choice for larger side sleepers. However, some people may feel some strain along their shoulders and hips. A firmer mattress will be required for heavier stomach sleepers. Individuals in this category will most likely feel their hips slip out of alignment while on the Saatva Luxury Firm.

Lightweight Sleepers – Under 130lbs

The Amerisleep AS3 is a good choice for back sleepers who are light in weight. Lightweight persons, on the other hand, may experience tremendous pressure while lying on their side while sleeping. If this describes you, you may want to have a look at our selection of the best soft mattresses. It is expected that these alternatives will alleviate pain in the shoulders and hips. The Amerisleep AS3 is an excellent option for those who like a more compact mattress and prefer to sleep on their stomachs. If you sleep on your stomach, you need a mattress that is firm enough to maintain your body in proper alignment.

Regardless of the sleeping position, the Saatva Luxury Firm mattress is ideal for light sleepers. The combination of the firm pillow core and the plush pillow top results in a mattress that is both comfortable and supportive.

Saatva vs Amerisleep: Best Mattress Qualities

Here we are, guys, at the finish of our comparison of these two products. Following our comparison of the various mattresses, let’s see what the experts have to say about each one. Listed here, I’ll discuss the types of people who might enjoy each of these bed options.

First and foremost, I believe the Saatva is best suited for folks who prefer a firm, supporting, and bouncy feel to their mattress. As an innerspring mattress, this one has a buoyant lift designed to put the sleeper more “on top” of the mattress than “in it.” It’s a wonderful choice for those who prefer a more conventional look or who are looking for something that will last a long time. I’d add remark that couples will appreciate this mattress, as well! Why? The inside coil system is encased in a layer of high-density poly foam edge support, which helps to increase the mattress’ useful surface area. In other words, if you and your bed partner want to take a break from hugging or want to switch up your sleeping position, you two can go all the way to the sides of the bed.

The Amerisleep mattress, on the other hand, appears to be best suited for back sleepers looking for an all-foam experience. Like the Saatva, it is solid and supporting, but it does so in a more balanced and gentle manner. The top layer of memory foam provides a great amount of cushioning, but it shouldn’t overwhelm you. In addition, the Amerisleep mattress is delivered in a box, which, depending on your tastes, may be a more practical sleeping alternative. As a reminder, Amerisleep’s AS2 mattress is just one of five alternatives. It’s possible to select a firmer or a gentler option from the brand!

Saatva Best Features

  • Because of its solid support, the Saatva innerspring mattress could be ideal for back sleepers.
  • The coil-on-coil construction, which makes it easy to move around and change positions, may also be beneficial to those who sleep in multiple positions.
  • Finally, I’d recommend this mattress to any couple looking for a new mattress. All kinds of bed partners will appreciate the firm foam edge support!

Amerisleep Best Features

  • Designed for back sleepers who need relief from pressure and support in the shoulders, hips, and lower back.
  • In terms of memory foam mattresses that don’t get too heated while you sleep, the Amerisleep range is a shining example. You may want to consider Amerisleep if you’ve stayed away from the material because of its reputation for absorbing heat.
  • A wide range of firmness options are available with the Amerisleep brand, so there should be something for everyone. The AS1 mattress is the firmest, while the AS5 is the softest and most cuddly. It’s the amount of memory foam in the top comfort layer that makes a big difference in these two beds’ overall comfort.

Should you buy Amerisleep or Saatva?

In reality, these are two distinct items. Amerisleep beds are made for those of you who value warm coziness above everything else. They do give you the impression that you’re floating above the ground.

Satta takes advantage of old-school technology that has been turned into something modern and high-tech. This adds a lot of heft and responsiveness to the whole experience.

There is no right or wrong answer, but rather a matter of personal preference and whether or not you’re searching for a specific outcome. Both beds meet their intended purpose flawlessly. Those who sleep on their stomachs should consider the Saatva. Each one works great if you prefer to sleep on your back and don’t move around a lot at night. Think about whether or not you want coils.


Inquiring minds want to know more about Amerisleep and Saatva. Some of the most frequently asked questions have been answered below!

Which mattress is better, Amerisleep or Saatva?

The most important thing to keep in mind while looking for a new mattress is that it should meet your specific sleeping preferences. Saatva is a fantastic option for light persons, whereas Amerisleep is best for side sleepers of average weight.

How long will Amerisleep and Saatva mattresses last?

There is no doubt in our minds that both mattresses will survive at least ten years.

Can you flip Amerisleep and Saatva mattresses?

Both mattresses cannot be flipped. Flipping a mattress would be a waste of time because both beds are built with support coils on the bottom and soft foam on top.

Rate this post