Updated at: 15-01-2023 - By: Jane

Mattresses from Casper and Loom & Leaf, two of the most popular online mattress retailers, are both high-quality and reasonably priced. In addition to mattresses, both companies sell bed frames and other sleep-related items.

There are a wide selection of mattress in a box mattresses available from Casper, making it an excellent option for a wide spectrum of customers. The Casper Hybrid, Wave Hybrid, and Nova Hybrid are all part of a hybrid series that also includes the all-foam Casper and Casper Element.

A luxurious mattress at an affordable price is what Saatva’s Loom & Leaf is all about. All-foam Loom & Leaf mattresses are available in Relaxed Firm and Firm firmness levels. It’s not compressed for shipment like most other online mattresses are. Customers receive a mattress and free in-home setup instead.

If you’re in the market for a new mattress, you can’t go wrong with either of these companies. We’ll examine the Casper and Loom & Leaf mattresses’ construction, sleeper ratings, and other relevant information to help you make an informed decision.

Loom & Leaf vs Casper: Similarities and Differences

Both the Loom & Leaf and Casper mattresses are excellent. All-foam memory foam mattress Loom & Leaf vs. all-foam memory foam mattress Casper. The Loom & Leaf and Casper mattresses will be compared in this article.

Main Similarities

  • Foam layers are used in both mattresses to provide both support and pressure reduction.
  • Both beds include a layer of memory foam on top that provides a lot of contouring hug and sinkage.
  • Both beds are comfortable. Both have cooling capabilities built into their comfort layers, which should keep sleepers from overheating.
  • It’s unlikely that you’ll feel any movement from one side of the bed on the other, as both beds performed well in our motion transfer test.

Main Differences

  • The Casper has only one firmness setting, while the Loom & Leaf has two: Relaxed Firm and Firm.
  • Both the Relaxed Firm Loom & Leaf and the Firm Loom & Leaf are slightly softer than the Casper.
    The Loom & Leaf is significantly more expensive than the Casper.
  • Unlike the Casper mattress, the Loom & Leaf mattress does not come compacted; instead, it is shipped uncompressed to your door.
  • With zoned support, the Casper offers firmer lumbar and softer neck and shoulder support. A zonal support system is not available on the Loom & Leaf.

Sizing Options

You may want to evaluate the mattress’s dimensions, weight, and height before getting into the nitty-gritty specifics.


However, it’s always a good idea to double-check that the dimensions of your new mattress match those of your current bed frame or foundation before making a purchase.

For persons who plan to move frequently, the mattress’s weight may be of particular importance. Even if the provider does not offer White Glove delivery, people with limited mobility may want to consider purchasing an easier-to-assemble mattress.

Those who have difficulty getting in and out of bed might consider purchasing a mattress that is at the same level as the foundation. Keep in mind that if you have a thicker mattress, you may need to get fitted sheets with deep pockets.


Casper Original Mattress

  • Height: 11″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King

Loom & Leaf

Loom & Leaf Mattress

  • Height: 12″
  • Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King, Split California King

Loom & Leaf’s mattresses are all the same height and weight, thus there is only one option. Despite its sumptuous appearance, the Loom & Leaf mattress is rather hefty and tall for an all-foam model, which may be a deal-breaker for some buyers. If you’re looking for something a little smaller, the mattress comes in king and queen sizes, as well as California King and split king.

As a result, Casper has a broader range of mattress heights and weights, with a 10-inch to 13-inch profile and the lightest mattress at 68 pounds. A Casper mattress can be found to fit the needs of most buyers regardless of personal preference.

Even though the all-foam Casper and Element mattresses are the smallest and lightest, their average profile allows them to provide a full comfort system on top of a solid support core. With only 11 inches in height, the Casper Hybrid mattress may be an excellent option for those who enjoy the feel of a hybrid mattress but are also looking for a more slender bed.

Wave and Nova hybrids are the thickest because of their thick comfort layers and pocketed coil support core. When getting in and out of bed is an issue, people who prefer a taller mattress with more edge support may choose these types. The hybrid Casper models, on the other hand, may necessitate greater effort to move or rotate.

Construction and Materials Comparison

Most mattresses are made up of two primary parts: a comfort layer system and a support core.

The comfort layers are the first points of contact between the body and the mattress, and they have the greatest impact on how pleasant it is for the sleeper. Polyfoam, memory foam, latex, micro-coils, cotton, and wool are all common materials for the comfort layer.

To keep the spine in alignment and prevent the sleeper from bottoming out, the mattress’s support core is located deeper in the mattress. Polyfoam, latex, or innersprings are the most common materials used in support cores.

If you’re looking for a mattress that has a lot of the same features as other mattresses, you’ll be disappointed. Casper and Loom & Leaf will be dissected in detail to see how their construction impacts their performance.


Five mattresses are currently available from Casper, two of which are all-foam and the other three are hybrids. A polyester, upcycled cotton, rayon, Lycra spandex, and recycled polyester from bottles blend is used to make all mattress covers.

Casper Mattress

There are three layers in total in the Casper Original, which is an all-foam mattress.

  • AirScape polyfoam has an open-cell, aerated 1.5-inch thickness.
  • Memory foam with a three-zone design.
  • Polyfoam core with a 7-inch thickness.

To keep you cool while you sleep, the aerated polyfoam helps move heat away from the mattress surface. Firmer memory foam in the mattress’ middle third gives lumbar support while also softening the shoulders in the second layer.

Casper Hybrid

Pocketed coils support the Casper Hybrid’s comparable design to the original Casper.

  • Open-cell, aerated AirScape polyfoam is 1.5 inches thick.
  • Memory foam with three distinct zones, measuring two inches thick
  • 6 inches of pocketed coils encased in a 7-inch foam encasement

For those who weigh over 230 pounds, the pocketed coils add bounce and breathability, as well as a more robust support system. The edges of the bed are protected by a foam encasement.

Wave Hybrid

There are additional layers of latex and other speciality foams with an emphasis on cooling in the Wave Hybrid:

  • Open-cell AirScape polyfoam laminated with cooling gel is 1 inch thick.
  • Inch thick AirScape latex in open-cell form.
  • 1.5 inches of memory foam with three distinct comfort zones
  • Zoned polyfoam with targeted gel pods is 1.5 inches thick.
  • 6 inches of pocketed coils encased in a 7-inch foam encasement

The gel pods are strategically positioned under the waist and lower back to provide additional lumbar support and help maintain spinal alignment. All layers use surface modification technologies to increase airflow and relieve pressure in the hip and shoulder regions. Similar to the Casper hybrid, the mattress has a pocketed coil support core and an outside layer of foam for bounce and edge support.

Nova Hybrid

Casper’s newest mattress, the Nova Hybrid, is an extra-plush hybrid mattress with numerous layers of customized support.

  • Open-cell polyfoam from AirScape.
  • A layer of 3-zone ice Open-cell polyfoam from AirScape
  • 7-zone transitional memory foam, 2 inches thick
  • 6 inches of pocketed coils encased in a 7-inch foam encasement

The Nova Hybrid mattress features the same breathable AirScape polyfoam layers and pocketed coil foundation as the Casper Wave Hybrid mattress. A layer of memory foam, separated into seven support zones, replaces the gel pod layer. In this layer, the hips and shoulders are cushioned, while the lumbar area remains stiffer.

Casper Element

With just two layers, the Casper Element is a low-cost alternative to the Casper mattress.

  • 3 inches of open-cell polyurethane foam from AirScape
  • core of high-density polyfoam 6.5 inches in diameter

While Casper’s Airscape polyfoam is used in the Element, it’s reinforced with a durable polyfoam core. In comparison to the other Casper models, this one has a harder surface and does a better job at pressure relief and motion isolation.

Loom & Leaf

Loom and Leaf’s all-foam mattress is available in two firmness levels: Relaxed Firm and Firm. Mattresses in both firmness levels have an organic cotton cover quilted with 5/8-inch foam and the same internal composition:

  • 3 inches of gel-infused mixed memory foam
  • Foam transitional to 2 inches in thickness
  • High-density polyfoam core measuring six inches thick

The top layer of memory foam is aerated and gel-infused to decrease heat buildup. Also included in this layer is phase change material in the lumbar area to help maintain body temperature and correct spinal alignment.

It is the second layer of memory foam that determines the firmness of the mattress. This layer provides pressure relief for the contours in both versions. Because it doesn’t hug the body as tightly, the Firm variant is more comfortable for sex and more temperature neutral.

In-Depth Ratings

When it comes to mattresses, there are a lot of options to choose from. The following characteristics may help you narrow down your options while evaluating the benefits of each mattress. There is no right or wrong answer here; it’s just a matter of prioritizing some of these factors above others based on your personal preferences and needs.

  • Durability: Mattresses are a substantial investment, and the longer they last, the more value you’ll get out of them. As a result, sags and persistent body impressions might diminish the mattress’ ability to support and relieve pressure. If you can afford it, a higher-quality mattress may be worth the additional cost.
  • Motion Isolation: Sharing a bed necessitates motion isolation. Those who are particularly sensitive to their partner’s movements may find a motion-isolation-focused bed particularly appealing. Polyfoam and latex mattresses can also provide excellent motion isolation, but memory foam is widely considered to be the finest. Individually wrapped coils in hybrid mattresses may reduce motion transfer because the coils can move independently of each other.
  • Sex: Because they don’t restrict movement, mattresses constructed of responsive materials are the most preferred choice for sex. There are a variety of latex and hybrid mattresses that provide some bounce for couples. Despite the fact that some people find all-foam mattresses to be excessively conforming, they do have the advantage of giving traction, so it all relies on personal preference. Couples should also take noise, edge support, and temperature neutrality into account.
  • Temperature Neutrality: Mattresses with breathable materials like latex, or those with an innerspring support core that allows for airflow, tend to have the best temperature neutrality. All-foam mattresses have a bad name for retaining body heat, but newer versions employ a variety of heat dissipation methods to combat this. Mattresses that “hug” the body and don’t allow heat to escape may not be ideal for hot sleepers.
  • Pressure Relief: Pressure points in the hips and shoulders should be relieved, while the weight of the body is distributed to prevent pressure buildup in places that are not supported, such as the lower back. An appropriate mattress firmness can help alleviate aches and pains, especially if your body type and sleeping habit are taken into consideration. Additionally, some mattresses offer zoning, which provides additional padding and targeted support in regions like as the lumbar region.
  • Off-gassing: When a new mattress is unwrapped for the first time, it is common for it to generate some off-gassing odors. Polyfoam and memory foam, as well as other synthetic foams, produce volatile organic compounds (VOCs). Even though the odors aren’t harmful and normally go away in a few hours to a few days, those who are sensitive to scents may find them bothersome.
  • Ease of Movement: Choosing a mattress that is easy to move around on may be preferable for persons who regularly change positions in their sleep. Firmer surfaces, which don’t sink as much, and responsive surfaces, which respond more quickly to pressure, are usually the best for mobility. As a result, hybrid, latex, or harder polyfoam mattresses are preferred by combination sleepers.
  • Edge Support: Extra edge support, whether in the form of firmer coils or a high-density polyfoam encasement, is common on mattresses to keep them from sinking in the center. Sitting or sleeping along the edge of the bed is made more comfortable by the presence of solid, well-formed edges. Couples sharing a smaller-sized bed may find this very useful in order to make the most of the available space. Mattresses with thin comfort layers, such as hybrid mattresses, are less likely to compress around the edges.

Our review of the Casper and Loom & Leaf mattresses follows.



Casper Original MattressCasper Original HybridCasper Wave HybridCasper ElementCasper Nova Hybrid
FirmnessMedium (5)Medium (5)Medium (5)Medium Firm (6)Medium (5)
Durability 3/5 3/5 4/5 2/5 4/5
Motion Isolation 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5
Sex 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5
Sleeps Cool 3/5 4/5 4/5 3/5 3/5
Pressure Relief 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5 4/5
Off-Gassing 3/5 3/5 3/5 2/5 3/5
Ease of Movement 3/5 4/5 4/5 3/5 4/5
Edge Support 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5 3/5

Loom & Leaf

Loom & Leaf Mattress
FirmnessMedium Firm (6), Firm (8)
Durability 3/5
Motion Isolation 4/5
Sex 2/5
Sleeps Cool 3/5
Pressure Relief 4/5
Off-Gassing 2/5
Ease of Movement 3/5
Edge Support 2/5

Prices and Sizing

Everything from low-cost mattresses to high-end luxury beds may be found on the market. There are a number of variables that contribute to the cost of a mattress:

  • Depending on the kind of mattress
  • There are a lot of layers and the mattress’s total thickness to consider.
  • Whether the materials utilized are organic or not, as well as their certifications.
  • The origin of the materials and the manufacturing location
  • Phase-change material or unique foams can be added to the product.
  • regulations regarding shipping and sleep trials

Although quality and price are sometimes linked, they are not always. It may be tempting to buy the most costly mattress you can afford, but it’s better to think about what you value in a mattress before making a final decision. There are a variety of price points to choose from, and most manufacturers run regular specials that can significantly lower the original price.


Casper Original MattressCasper Original HybridCasper Wave HybridCasper ElementCasper Nova Hybrid
Twin XL$795$1,095$2,195$299$1,595
California King$1,495$1,795$3,295$574$2,695
Split King
Split California King

Loom & Leaf

Loom & Leaf Mattress
Twin XL$1,299
California King$2,299
Split King$2,598
Split California King$2,676

For an all-foam mattress, the Loom & Leaf mattress costs more than others. White Glove delivery and optional old mattress removal are included in the Loom & Leaf’s price, which often costs $100 to $150 from other manufacturers.

The Loom & Leaf’s closest competitor is the original Casper mattress. The Loom & Leaf has a higher price tag because of its more complex construction. The Loom & Leaf mattress is built with higher-density foams than the Casper, resulting in a longer lifespan. Which mattress is best for you depends on more than just price and durability; it also depends on how you like to sleep.

Casper has a mattress for every price point, from a simple all-foam model to a number of luxury hybrids, beyond their flagship mattress. Casper Element is a good option for budget-conscious consumers, while the luxury models are better suited to those with more particular needs. If you’re a hot sleeper or need more support, the Wave and Nova hybrids may be just what you’ve been looking for.

Trial, Warranty, and Delivery

Mattress businesses go to great lengths to ensure that their policies are customer-friendly, so that customers can rest easy when they buy a new mattress.



Mattress-in-a-boxes are supplied for free with most online purchases of beds. This means that they are packaged, compressed, and transported via FedEx or UPS ground service to your front door. Deliveries might take anything from a few days to a few weeks depending on where the mattress is sent from.

Remove all the packaging and plastic by placing the mattress on the bed frame or foundation and then unwrapping it. With two persons, it may be easier to complete this task. However, the mattress may take a few days before it returns to its full size.

Contiguous United States and Canadian provinces are eligible for free shipping on Casper mattresses. There is an additional charge for orders in Alaska, Hawaii, and Canada.

There are no traditional mattress-in-a-box processes for the Loom & Leaf, as it is not compressed for shipping.


White Glove Delivery

A White Glove delivery service is provided by some mattress firms, and it entails the delivery and setup of your mattress in the room of your choice by a delivery team. For an extra cost, you may be able to have your old mattress taken away as well.

Loom & Leaf mattresses ship with White Glove delivery, which is included in the mattress’s price. Customers who want to get rid of their old mattresses can do so for free during the checkout process. In the case that a customer cancels an order for an already-made mattress, Loom & Leaf offers expedited shipping.

For an additional cost, Casper provides White Glove delivery and the removal of your old mattress. Contiguous United States and significant Canadian cities are covered by this service.

Shipping Outside the Contiguous United States

It’s not uncommon for orders to be shipped to Hawaii or Alaska to be subject to additional fees and extended delivery delays. For logistical reasons, White Glove or expedited delivery may not be a possibility for everyone.


In-home sleep trials for online mattress purchases are common. As a result, you are able to test out the mattress in the comfort of your own home, with the assurance that if it doesn’t work out for you, you can return it. There is an industry standard for sleep experiments that last at least 90 nights, with some sleep trials lasting up to a year or more.

If you decide to return your mattress, most companies will arrange for a pickup, but some may charge a modest fee for doing so. It is common practice to give mattresses away or recycle them when people return them.

Returns are subject to a small transportation cost for Loom & Leaf, which offers a 180-night sleep trial. With a free return policy, Casper provides a 100-night sleep trial. Both companies do not demand a break-in time.


To guard against manufacturing and craftsmanship flaws, most mattresses contain a warranty as part of the purchase price. If a mattress is found to be defective, the decision to repair or replace it is left to the discretion of the manufacturer. Prorated warranties, in which the client pays a portion of the repair costs as time goes on, are a good option for warranties.

Indentations in the body that are deeper than a specific depth are normally covered by a guarantee, as are cover flaws and foam splitting or cracking. As a general rule, warranties do not cover changes in foam softness, such as the softening that occurs over time as a result of regular wear and tear. The warranty on a mattress is nearly always null and void if it is not placed on a proper base.

A 10-year limited guarantee is included with each Casper mattress. After the first two years, repairs to the Loom & Leaf mattress are subject to a $99 transportation fee each way. For a prorated discount and a $99 transportation cost, customers can choose the Fairness Replacement Option, which allows them to keep their damaged mattress while receiving a new one at a discounted rate.

Who Should Pick Casper:

  • This mattress is best for people who sleep on their stomachs the majority of the time. The centre of the mattress is firmer under the hip area because of the zoned construction. The hips should not sink in too far as a result of this and should instead remain in neutral position.
  • You want a mattress that is more comfortable. The Casper mattress is noticeably softer than the other one. The Casper mattress is ideal if you like a mattress that is a little softer.
  • Balanced foam is what you prefer. Casper is a better option if you prefer a foam mattress but don’t want to dig down too far. The Casper mattress is by far the most comfortable of the two. Additionally, the mattress should allow you to easily get up and down from it.

Who Should Pick Loom & Leaf:

  • Heavy people- This mattress is thicker than Casper and has high-density foams that are generally more supportive and durable for those who weigh more than 190lbs. As a result, the Loom & Leaf mattress should provide superior support for larger people. Because the comfort layers are thicker, there should be less of a danger of bottoming out and reaching solid support layers.
  • This should be the better option if you desire something stiffer than the Loom & Leaf, which is definitely firmer.
  • Those who want the original memory foam feel should find that the Loom & Leaf is a good match for their preferences. It includes a thick layer of memory foam on top, so you’ll feel like you’re in a quicksand.


In the end, choosing between the Casper and Loom & Leaf mattresses shouldn’t be too tough given the differences are so great. The Casper is better for stomach sleepers and those who prefer a more balanced foam feel, while the Loom & Leaf is better for larger individuals and those who prefer a more traditional memory foam feel.

Consumers should read this material a few times, examine their individual wants and preferences, and then come to a more informed decision after evaluating their options.

Rate this post