Updated at: 16-01-2023 - By: Jane

Online mattress retailers Casper and Nolah are both well-known for selling foam mattresses. Three mattress variations are available from Casper, but the company’s original product remains the most popular. With only one mattress design, Nolah is a lesser-known but nevertheless popular company.

For your benefit, I’m going to outline the significant similarities and distinctions between each one. Stay tuned for our comparison of the Nolah vs Casper mattresses to find out which is best for you!

Nolah vs. Casper

Find out which of the two mattresses is best for you by comparing them below!

Key Similarities

  • Both mattresses have a thickness of 10 inches and are made of all-foam.
  • Both provide cooling options and are expected to be fairly breathable.
  • Two different types of foam are used to ensure the best possible comfort.
  • In the same ballpark.
  • Shipping and ample sleep trials are included in both deals.

Key Differences

  • Nolah is noticeably softer than Casper.
  • Casper has four layers of foam, whereas Nolah has three.
  • Nolah’s support layer is thicker.
  • It has a layer between the two comfort layers and the foundation layer, Casper’s transition layer.
  • A layer of memory foam is incorporated into Casper’s construction for additional pressure alleviation and body contouring.
  • Nolah’s 120-day trial term is longer than Casper’s 100-day trial period.

Nolah Construction

The Nolah mattress’ construction is seen in the image below. Here’s how it works:

  • The viscose cover is thin, soft, and allows for plenty of airflow, so it has no impact on the overall comfort of the mattress.
  • AirFoam, a patented 2-inch layer on top, is supposed to ease pressure better than memory foam while also ensuring that users sleep cool during their nighttime use.
  • One inch of Avena foam, which resembles latex and provides some bounce, lies beneath the AirFoam.
  • For a foam mattress, the base layer is 7 inches of 1.8 lb. density poly foam, which is standard.

Casper Construction

  • Stretchy, breathable, and unaffected by the mattress’s feel are just a few of the benefits of using a lightweight, premium fabric.
  • 1.5 inches of latex-like specialized polyfoam from the manufacturer make up the top layer. Casper refers to this material as “open-cell” because of the tiny holes it contains for ventilation and the good bounce it provides.
  • To assist the mattress fit to your body, the following layer is 1.5 inches of 3.5 lb. density memory foam. This layer aids the mattress in conforming to the specific contours of the body by relieving pressure points.
  • Another 1.5-inch “transition layer” of 2.5-pound density polyfoam completes the third layer. As a transitional layer between the softer comfort layers and firmer support, this one is designed to help guarantee even weight distribution and reduce pressure points.
  • A 1.8-pound density polyfoam foundation layer is employed in many different bed-in-a-box models.


Construction Differences/Notes

  • In terms of durability, I would give Nolah a little edge over the other mattresses.
  • Compared to Casper, Nolah offers a more forgiving top layer and a softer feel all over.
  • On top of Casper’s base layer, there’s an additional transition layer.
  • It is important that both mattresses are airy and allow you to sleep comfortably all night long.
  • In comparison to the Nolah, Casper will have more bounce.

Firmness/Feel Differences

Casper is a little firmer than typical, but if you put enough pressure on it, you can push into it just as much as you can the Nolah. The only difference is that Casper returns more swiftly and powerfully. Make sure you watch these videos to see how they compare and contrast to each other! Nolah is softer than Casper, in my opinion.

Motion Transfer Differences

As a result, they are able to withstand a lot of pressure without transferring motion. Each is an excellent choice for couples because of this. Because it sinks so much, Nolah has a slight advantage here because it doesn’t truly transfer motion. On the Casper, if you bounce around too much, the person next to you will notice. In order to see for yourself, watch these videos.

Pick Nolah If:

  • Because you sleep on your side, Nolah’s softness makes it ideal for absorbing pressure.
  • As a result, you prefer to sleep “in” rather than “on” your mattress, which has a quicksand-like feel to it.

Pick Casper If:

  • In the event that you sleep on your stomach or back, Casper’s firmness and zonal support structure make it a superb choice.
  • For those who favor well-established firms, Casper has been through quite a bit of media coverage and has had to remodel its flagship mattress a few times. Casper is the best option if you desire a brand with a better established track record.

Casper vs Nolah: Materials

Casper Materials

The Casper mattress is 12 inches thick and is made up of four layers of foam. At the foam’s surface, we begin. With an open cell foam layer, this is where the bulk of the pressure-relieving comfort will come from. As a result of open cell technology, airflow is created and heat is able to dissipate. To further alleviate pressure, there is a second layer of foam.

The next layer is a supporting foam layer that is zoned for comfort. Targeted support and pressure alleviation are provided to the parts of the body that require them most. Adjusting the firmness of your mattress to suit your preferences and the needs of your body.

In the end, the bed is built on a foundation of high-density memory foam. The next layer is a zoned foam support layer.

A plush polyester cover completes the package. While this cover can be washed, it should not be put in the dryer because it will shrink and no longer fit..


Nolah Materials

Three layers of foam make up the Nolah Original Mattress, which is 10″ thick and weighs 350 lbs. Their proprietary AirFoam is used in the first layer of the Nolah. Their bed is filled with Nolah’s foam. Memory foam’s responsiveness, but without the heat retention, can be found in this product. The majority of the bed’s pressure reduction comes from this foam.

The second 1″ layer of foam creates a responsive supporting layer that resembles latex in terms of its responsiveness. Makes it easier to get into and out of bed, as well as to move around while in the bed.

There is a 7″ thick layer of support foam at the bottom of the mattress. This hard foam provides the mattress with structure, allowing the top layers to contour and support the sleeper more effectively. This mattress’s cover is comprised of a natural viscose material, which helps to keep its sleeper cool and wick away any accumulated moisture.

Browse Casper Customer Reviews

Both my husband and I suffer from debilitating problems with our bones and muscles. My military service and my husband’s recent run-in with a truck have left us both scarred. Consequently, we’ve been on the lookout for a more restful night’s sleep for some time now. There was no difference in the quality of our beds, no matter how much we paid on them. Even though we weren’t convinced by Glen Beck’s claims about the Casper mattresses, I ultimately caved after hearing him rave about them time and time again. We had just come to terms with the fact that suffering would be a permanent part of our lives. The cost was significantly lower than anticipated, and placing the order was a breeze. It took significantly less time than expected for the mattress and base to arrive. The foundation was a breeze to assemble, and once it was, we watched in wonder as the mattress box expanded to suit the frame. We weren’t sure what to expect when we went to sleep that night because everything seemed so different. When I awoke seven hours later (after the longest sleep either of us had had in years), I was the first to notice that there was absolutely NO PAIN in any of my stiff, painful joints. The same thing happened to my spouse! That’s why we’re so grateful to you, Casper, for giving us back our pain-free mornings and deep, rejuvenating sleep all night long. Incredibly, we are awed by your genius. Brava!!!


Trial Period & Warranty

Casper’s mattresses come with a 100-night risk-free trial and a ten-year warranty. In contrast, Nolah provides a 120-night trial period and a 15-year warranty period. It is important to remember that these warranties take into consideration regular wear and tear.

Despite the lengthy trial periods, you should be able to establish if a mattress is good for you within a matter of 30 days or less.. Once your body gets used to a new mattress, this is typically how long it takes. Casper’s trial period and warranty are fine, but Nolah’s are a little better.

Casper vs Nolah Mattress – Our Verdict:

For side sleepers in search of pressure alleviation and an all-foam mattress, none of these options should be overlooked. Comfort, structure, and materials are so comparable that it is nearly impossible to make a decision.

As a result, the following are your options. The Casper mattress is two inches thicker than the Nolah mattress, so if you like a thicker mattress, we recommend it. The Nolah, on the other hand, features newer materials that may help you sleep a little cooler and have less off-gassing than the Casper mattress. Both of these mattresses are excellent at relieving strain on your body’s aches and pains. Isn’t that great?

Rate this post